I find Standard Hip Action to be conducive of a Shoulder Turn Takeaway. That "perceptible slackness in the Hip and Shoulder relationship", which Lynn referred to above, can IMO easily cause the Hands to move back too low and too much inside.
That's not saying that you cannot produce wonderful Swings with Standard Hip Action. And I agree that the slackness in the Hip/Shoulder relationship seems to fit the Swinger's pattern, particularly the Dragging Clubhead Takeaway. But much more difficult to master than Delayed Hip Action.
Nice....
But why are you implying that standard hip action which is described as actuating the shoulders in both directions has a "perceptible slackness..." when in fact he makes the distinction between zero hip action and standard with the following description
"10-15-ZERO HIP ACTION except with zero hip turn, this can resemble standard hip action above, but there is usually a perceptible slackness between the hip and shoulder relationship in both directions, the motion is a hip turn only, not a true action in either direction"
Unlike Standard hip action in which there is not a slackness because the hips are actuating the shoulders both ways, it is a true action in both directions
Threaded Mode
