Originally Posted by Meditation
|
|
You are not going to have much wrist cock if the back of the hand is inline with the wrist joint unless you alter the grip. A correct grip and motion will allow a maximum wrist cock well past 90 degrees without requiring any physical change in the grip whatsoever.
|
Also , an attempt to form a visually flat left wrist at Top or Finish when you're starting with a slightly turned left hand grip type (as you should IMO) can only be accomplished via the introduction of some Horizontal Wrist Motion ..... An arching motion. Though small , this Horizontal wrist motion is still a "no no" as it breaks the Vertical only , Plane of the Left Wrist Cock and the Left Arm Flying Wedge and therefor Homers concept of Rhythm is lost.
Only the weakest , thumb on top truly vertical to the plane left hand grip types would show a truly flat left wrist at Top.
With a slightly Turned Left Hand grip type , a purely Vertical Left Hand Wrist Cock motion will see the Flat Left Wrist at Top have a slight bend or cup to it visually . Its Flat (capital F) , aka geometrically Flat but not visually or literally flat (lower case f).
To be blunt and with all due respect to several great GSED's who have come before us......there is some confusion around this issue as there were guys teaching a visually flat left wrist at Top and at Finish and through the Finish Swivel. Some even taught a flat left wrist in Finish Swivel with the palm facing the sky . Lynn does not teach any of this!!!!! That palm facing upwards towards the sky thing is an over swivel by the way.
My personal opinion is that being the gentleman Lynn is and never wishing to offend , he has never directly outlined this difference in the teaching of the Wrist Conditions. No doubt out of respect for those other teaching greats . But if you read his posts carefully his ideas on the Wrist Conditions are all here. I have in my records, emails where he kindly took me through the whole thing , with photo's of pro's displaying the conditions he likes.
Lynn teaches a Finish with the club running like an arrow through the ears , the left palm facing the target (not the Plane Line of the left ear or or ) and per Bob McDonald , Golf 1927 an "inward bend " of the left wrist. In an email to me he said "The LW is palm up to the plane at the end of FS (Finish Swivel) then rotates palm to target with the shoulder turn while retaining its "inward bend".
Dont get me wrong. The Flat Left Wrist is critical , Rolling the Flat Left Wrist through impact is all important . But like all things Flat can be over done to the point where it becomes a fault. A flail killer , a block to free wheeling motion , the ruination of the left arm flying wedge and Rhythm , capital R.
Lynn sent me these photos with a rhetorical "Any questions?" A picture is said to be worth a thousand words. Perhaps it can answer a thousand questions.